This seems to be so straightforward that I can't believe I haven't found the answer in the SPSS help or online - I must be missing something.
I have two scale variables, let's call them $X$ and $Y$. They are likert scale variables measuring agreement with attitude statements for two items that are thought to measure the same construct. It's two separate questions from the same instrument, given to the same sample (which was drawn from the same population). (*)
These two variables have some distributions that have some overlap. My question is, how do we test the hypothesis that the two distributions are or are not different (to a p<0.05 level)? (Which, I think, could imply that the items are indeed measuring the same construct.)
This seems to call for a t-test comparing whether the means $\mu_X$ and $\mu_Y$ of the two distributions are equal, testing the hypothesis: $\mu_X=\mu_Y.$
But I've looked through the documentation of the "Compare Means," "Independent samples T-Test," and "Paired samples T-test" in SPSS, both in the GUI and the command syntax, and I can't find how to do this type of test.
I must be missing something?
(*) I know there is some controversy about whether to treat Likert Scale variables as ordinal or scale variables, but for this preliminary analysis I'm comfortable treating them as scale.