# Synthetic Model Object

I want to test a multinomial logit model that has been published by another author against one that I have developed. I have his coefficients, but neither the standard errors nor the model fit statistics.

Is there a way to create an mlogit object without estimating it? Can I create a blank object and fill it with the coefficient estimates? Could this be used for prediction? Are there pitfalls to doing so?

-
What makes the models different? Is it that you use different covariates? –  Michael Chernick Sep 20 '12 at 20:49
I don't have his dataset, so I cannot estimate his model. I have variables in my dataset he didn't use, and he used variables I don't have exactly. There is another dataset that I could test both his model and my model against, however, and I'm wondering how I could go about doing this. –  gmacfarlane Sep 21 '12 at 0:23

I assume you have the estimated parameters in his model so that given a data point you can make a prediction. Then you could do predictions with both models and compare them. I see no problem with doing this as long as the comparison is meaningful (in this case is the test data set of the type that both models were built to predict.

I am not familiar with mlogit so I cannot tell you if and how you can do it with that particular logistic regression program. But many software products have fit and predict options where if you want to predict a new observation you just supply the model formula.

Aside from that it seems that it would be easy for you to program it yourself by just plugging in the data point to the model formula and computing the predicted logit or through the inverse transformation the predicted probability p.

-