Take the 2-minute tour ×
Cross Validated is a question and answer site for people interested in statistics, machine learning, data analysis, data mining, and data visualization. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm a bit stucked and just wondering about which regression technic to use. Respondents were asked to provide a particular percentage value from 0-100. Sadly, these percentages are not accessible in the dataset, but were ranked into nine categories (0-8). The categories are thought of representing a performance measure, ranging from 0 ('low performer') to 8 ('highest performer'). To notice, the categories do consist of different value ranges, so not really even intervals. In general, I'm interested in predicting the effect of some ordinal IVs on performance. Referring to the descriptive statistics / frequencies, my DV appears to be heavily right skewed. Particularly, one third of all observations (N=400) is attributed to 0, whereas the rest appears to be bell shaped.

Many many thanks in upfront!

Chris

share|improve this question
1  
You call your data ordinal, and appear to suggest it is discrete. This appears to conflict your statement on normality. Can you clarify this? –  Nick Sabbe Mar 19 '13 at 14:07
    
Thanks for the fast response. –  Chris J Mar 19 '13 at 14:18
    
Respondents were asked to provide a particular percentage value from 0-100. Sadly, these percentages are not accessible in the dataset, but were ranked into the mentioned nine categories (0-8). The categories have different value ranges, so i thought of ordinal discrete data, rather than interval data. Because most of the respondents were placed in category 0, i referred to a non-normal distribution... –  Chris J Mar 19 '13 at 14:26
    
You may want to edit that comment into your question. Another addition will be needed, though: what kind of "effect" are you interested in? Your categories seem rather arbitrary, so a transition from one to the next is perhaps not really telling, or is it? –  Nick Sabbe Mar 19 '13 at 14:44
1  
If your data are only ordinal how do you know how skew it is? Are you implicitly assuming nearly equal intervals? (Edit ... I see from your comment that perhaps you do have additional information that might make it correspond to apparent skewness) When you say "whereas the rest is quite normally distributed from 1-8" - you can't mean normally distributed. You probably mean something like 'sort of bell shaped, reasonably symmetric' –  Glen_b Mar 19 '13 at 14:44

2 Answers 2

I think you may be mixing different issues in the same package. First things first. As @whuber has just pointed, it is not clear whether your DV is really ordinal, or only your IVs. That would configure very different scenarios, depending on such clarification. For instance, if your DV is also ordinal, you could (and maybe even should) go for a Ordinal Logistic Regression, just as mentioned by @Scortchi. The skewed distribution of such a DV would be less than a problem in that framework.

Actually, being precise, the distribution of even a continuous DV is, by itself, less of a problem. What you should be more worried about is the distribution of the residuals of your whole model, not of the variables themselves. It is a common mistake to pay attention to the distribution of the variables not of the residuals.

So, if your DV is continuous and the distribution of the residuals is heavily skewed, you should try first to transform your DV (log transformation being the standard, but in some cases you may need to power the DV or to square root it). If no transformation of the DV works, try also transforming any continuous IV. If you still have no good luck here, I would go for a robust regression, which allows for much less well behaved distribution of residuals. It is fairly usefull, for instance, when you have strong bell-shaped distribution of the residuals, i.e. heavy tails in both sides (a scenario that may be very hard to solve through transformation of variables). In R, it can be accomplished very well with lmrob function.

But anyway, at the end of your question, you mention that one third of the DV observations are equal zero. This case may also suggest that you may have a zero-inflated scenario and, thus, may need to look for models that can account for this kind of issue, such as the Zero-Inflated Regression models.

Hope this helps, but any further insights depend on you better clarifying your variables and the specification of your models.

share|improve this answer

Ordinal logistic regression might well suit what you've described. You would not be assuming that the difference between, say, '7' & '8' was equal to the difference between '6' & '7', but only that the categories of the dependent variable are ordered.

share|improve this answer
    
"I'm interested in predicting the effect of some ordinal IVs on performance" suggests that the independent variables are discrete and ordered. It is not clear--unless I missed something in the comments--what the dependent variable is like. It might or might not have a "bell shaped" distribution and it might or might not be discrete. This is a very confusing question due to its vagueness. –  whuber Apr 16 '13 at 18:11
    
@whuber: My reading was that the dependent variable is performance, that it's discrete & ordered, & also the IVs are discrete & ordered. –  Scortchi Apr 16 '13 at 18:17

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.