304 reputation
6
bio website
location
age
visits member for 11 months
seen Oct 18 '12 at 13:17
stats profile views 95

Oct
18
accepted Is it possible to have a variable that acts as both an effect modifier and a confounder?
Oct
5
awarded  Nice Question
Sep
30
comment Possible projects for Data Analysis course?
My two cents: as it stands this question is way too open for a reasonably definitive answer. Second, unlike certain other subjective, non-definitive questions, I doubt this qualifies for community wiki.
Sep
30
revised Is it possible to have a variable that acts as both an effect modifier and a confounder?
added 46 characters in body
Sep
30
asked Is it possible to have a variable that acts as both an effect modifier and a confounder?
Sep
10
suggested suggested edit on How do I test a nonlinear association?
Sep
10
comment How do I test a nonlinear association?
@Macro and Michael to me fitting a model of the relation between $x$ and $y$ in a semi/non-parametric way is one way of testing the association between the two. Such a test could be extended by measuring the extent of association with the different ways you've each suggested. I think both answers and the follow-up here have been quite useful to me, sans the ad hominem. However, since my question did include how we could "label its nature", which could be interpreted as model-fitting, I'm going to stick with Macro's answer.
Sep
9
accepted Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
Sep
9
awarded  Commentator
Sep
9
comment Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
Is there some way of implementing a 2D KS test (any variation) in R? Package?
Sep
9
accepted How do I test a nonlinear association?
Sep
9
comment How do I test a nonlinear association?
I prefer this approach to the two separate rank correlations either side of $x=a$ because it examines the relation as whole. It's also better than the parametric model, so I've accepted this instead.
Sep
8
awarded  Supporter
Sep
8
comment How do I test a nonlinear association?
Essentially, I'd be splitting the x~y relation into two parts. Below x=a, the correlation by Spearman's rho is positive. Above x=a, the correlation by Spearman's rho is negative. I like this approach. However, is there also some way of parametrically testing whether the relationship between x and y fits an inverse parabola, i.e. $y = ax^2 + bx + c$, where $a$ is negative. Perhaps, this requires a custom statistical test?
Sep
8
comment Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
@MichaelChernick this question is independent of my previous post although that doesn't discount the possibility of overlap in answers.
Sep
8
revised Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
added 308 characters in body
Sep
8
comment Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
@MichaelChernick that's correct. I want to compare two curves based on two-dimensional points. However, I've rephrased my question to reflect the fact that basically I want to know whether the distribution of the (x,y) coordinates of the blue points is significantly different from the distribution of the (x,y) coordinates of the red points. I'd also want to know the directionality of this difference.
Sep
7
asked Test whether (x,y) of one set of data points is significantly greater than the (x,y) of another set of data points
Sep
7
asked How do I test a nonlinear association?
Jul
12
accepted Whether to stratify or do a simple random sampling from a set of papers to be compared?