Q2: As far as I know there are 2 good ways to test for causality. It is done by the design of the study. Two designs work here:
- In a situation where you can control ALL independent variables (usually in experiments). This makes sure that A is causing B, and there is no C causing the effect (and also not the reverse effect; B causing A).
- In longitudinal studies.
Q1: Rubin's Causal Model: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubin_causal_model
Q3: There is no "trick" to seeing whether the statistics of one single article are good. I find the most important questions you should ask yourself:
- Who did the research?
- What is to be gained by the researcher with a favorable outcome?