Skip to main content
added 413 characters in body
Source Link

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

Is there a deterministic way calculate this? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

Update: I'll include the Python script I ran to clarify what I meant by "Stochastically, it seems...":

import random
import statistics

trials = 10000
n = 100
m = 100

lens = []
for j in range(trials):
    k = []
    for x in range(n):
        k.append(random.randint(1,m))
    lens.append(len(list(set(k))))

print(statistics.median(lens), statistics.quantiles(lens, n=10))

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

Is there a deterministic way calculate this? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

Is there a deterministic way calculate this? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

Update: I'll include the Python script I ran to clarify what I meant by "Stochastically, it seems...":

import random
import statistics

trials = 10000
n = 100
m = 100

lens = []
for j in range(trials):
    k = []
    for x in range(n):
        k.append(random.randint(1,m))
    lens.append(len(list(set(k))))

print(statistics.median(lens), statistics.quantiles(lens, n=10))
deleted 11 characters in body
Source Link

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

What isIs there a deterministic way to formulatecalculate this question? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

What is a deterministic way to formulate this question? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

I am curious how to formulate a deterministic answer to a problem I have in mind. I have computed it stochastically, but am unsure of how to frame and compute the problem deterministically. My prob & stats classes are a few decades behind me...

Let's say that we have 100 people, and each person is asked to choose a number between 1 and 100 (inclusive). Maybe everyone chooses the same number, but this is unlikely. It is also unlikely that everyone chooses a different unique number. How many of the numbers from 1 to 100 will get picked?

Stochastically, it seems that somewhere between 59 and 67 of the numbers will be picked (10th percentile and 90th percentile respectively) with a median example resulting in 63 of the numbers being chosen.

Is there a deterministic way calculate this? What concepts are relevant? How does the formula vary for a different number of people? And for a different number of numbers to choose?

edited title
Link

Deterministic formula for average number of unique items picked

Source Link
Loading