My analysis includes, among others, three independent variables: X (interest rate), Y (type of rate; it is a dummy), and Z (likelihood of bankruptcy). I have transformed the latter into a categorical variable ZZ. To do so, I have used deciles (i.e., ZZ is 1 if the value of Z is lower than the 10th percentile of Z, etc). In some specifications of the model, I use the interaction term X·ZZ, and in others, Y·ZZ and X·Y·ZZ.

However, I have now the following doubt. Leaving aside other considerations, is there a statistical reason to use ZZ instead of Z (i.e., the categorical version of a continuous variable instead of the variable itself) in interaction terms? Does it make any difference the fact that the other variable in the relevant interaction terms is a dummy (Y) or a continuous variable (X)?

Thanks in advance.


(I assume you are fitting a linear model with variables X and Z or ZZ).

There is a difference in using a categorical variable (ZZ) or a continuous one (Z):

  • In case of using the continuos variable Z, you are assuming that the effect of X will depend on the value Z, and that this effect is linear. A possible result for example might be that the effect of X is two units higher for an extra unit of Z.

  • When you use the categorical feature, you assume that the effect of X is different for each possible value of ZZ. You allow the effect of X to be different for each discrete value of ZZ but don't imply linearity. An possible for example might be if ZZ=1, the effect of X=2. If ZZ=2, the effect of X=4. If ZZ=3, the effect of X=5.

The last model is actually the same as splitting your dataset up for each level of ZZ and fitting a liner of model with only X. You have separate linear models.

To really understand this, I suggest to transform the data Z into ZZ, and model first a continuous model and afterwards a categorical model and compare the outcomes. In R, this would be:

lm(Y ~ X*ZZ, data = data)
lm(Y ~ X * as.factor(ZZ), data = data)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.