I'm revising for an upcoming exam with old assignment questions, but I got this one wrong at the time and we aren't given model solutions. Looking for advice on whether or not my second attempt for A) is correct,and if not a tip in the right direction, and any hints on part B), thank you.

Let $X$ and $Y$ denote the respective outcomes when two fair dice are thrown. Let $U=\text{min}(X,Y)$, $V=\text{max}(X,Y)$, $S = U+V$, and $T=V-U$

A) Determine the conditional probability mass function for $U$ given $V=v$

B) Determine the joint mass function for $S$ and $T$

My Attempt:


$\begin{align} P(U=u|V=v)&=P(\text{min}(X,Y)=u|\text{Max}(X,Y)=v)\\ &=[P(X=u,Y=v)+P(X=v,Y=u)]/P(\text{max}(x,y)=v)\\ &=\frac{1}{18 \times P(\text{max}(x,y)=v)} \end{align}$

$\begin{align} P(\text{max}(x,y)=v)&=P(X=v,Y\leq v)+P(Y=v,X\leq v)\\ &=2 \times P(X=v,Y\leq v)\quad \text{(By symmetry)} \\ &=2\times(1/6)\times (v/6)\\ &=v/18 \end{align}$

Substituting back into the above gives the conditional distribution for $U$ given $V=v$ as $1/v$.

Edit: After revision the PMF for the maximum came out as (2v-1)/36 which means the above conditional pmf is definitely wrong


$\begin{align} P(S=s,T=t)&=P(U+V=s,V-U=t)\\ &=P(X+Y=s,|X-Y|=t)\\ &=P(X+Y=s,X-Y=t)+P(X+Y=s,X-Y=-t)\\ \vdots \\ &=P(Y=(s-t)/2,X=(s+t)/2)+P(X=(s-t)/2,Y=(s+t)/2) \end{align}$ I'm stuck here. A hint in the right direction would be greatly appreciated.


Draw a $6$" $\times$ $6$" square and divide it into a $6\times 6$ array of $36$ one-inch squares. Label the rows and columns with numbers $1$-$6$ and in each square, write down the values of $(X,Y)$, $U$, $V$, $S$ and $T$ in each square . Then, count!

  • $\begingroup$ That's what I answered initially, and it got marked wrong. I just can't see a way of expressing it in an actual pmf though, unless I do it in some sort of case by case basis. Any ideas? $\endgroup$ – Patrick Jun 6 '15 at 21:11
  • $\begingroup$ @Patrick Did you forget to count? If $\max(X,Y) = V$, its probability mass function is very definitely not $\frac{v}{18}$ for $1 \leq v \leq 6$. Since the numerators of $\frac{v}{18}$ sum to $1+2+3+4+5+6 = 21$, the pmf that you found does not satisfy the requirement $\sum_{v=1}^6 p_V(v) = 1$. $\endgroup$ – Dilip Sarwate Jun 6 '15 at 21:53
  • $\begingroup$ You're right, thanks for pointing that out. It just agreed with what I would expect the conditional pmf to be so I didn't bother checking. Will work on the problem again later and update it when I get something that works. $\endgroup$ – Patrick Jun 6 '15 at 23:03
  • $\begingroup$ I guess a rest helped me think because just after reading your comment I got the following: $P(max(X,Y)=v) = P(max(X,Y)<=v)-P(max(X,Y)<=v-1)$ =$P(X<=v,Y<=v)-P(X<=v-1,Y<=v-1)$ =$v^2/36 - (v-1)^2/36$ =$(2*v-1)/36$ Which does indeed sum to 1 over all possible values of v. Unless you can spot some flawed leap of logic in my reasoning when I changed the max into terms of X,Y. $\endgroup$ – Patrick Jun 6 '15 at 23:11
  • $\begingroup$ Consequently this must mean the joint PMF I derived in A) to find the conditional must be wrong, as 2/(2v-1) definitely does not sum to 1 as it should for some fixed v. It occurs to me that if you had $max(X,Y)=min(X,Y)$ then clearly the probability cannot be 1/18 as there is only one instance that could happen. Again now I'm confused how to express this without doing a case by case pmf. $\endgroup$ – Patrick Jun 6 '15 at 23:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.