I have to forecast sales for stores. So for that I am using ARIMA model.Here first we need to create times series object using ts function which takes frequency parameter.As far as I know we use 1=annual, 4=quarterly, 12=monthly but don't know sure what will be frequency for daily observations. I tried using 1,7,365 and number of observation as values for frequency parameter but with these I am not able to get proper plots and forecast.My second question is how to deal with 0 values for specific observation as they are producing errors as follows:

Error in na.fail.default(as.ts(x)) : missing values in object for acf() and pacf() 


Error in OCSBtest(x, m) : The OCSB regression model cannot be estimatedauto.arima() functions.

Here is the data: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-KJYBgmb044QlNUS3FhVFhUbE0/view?usp=sharing

Below is my code:


   mydata<- ts(data[,2], start=1, end=181, frequency = 7)
   plot(mydata, xlab="Day", ylab = "Sales")

   plot(diff(mydata),xlab="Day",ylab="Differenced Sales")
   plot(diff(log10(mydata)),ylab="Differenced Log (Sales)")

   par(mfrow = c(1,2))
   acf(ts(diff(log10(mydata))),main="ACF Sales")
   pacf(ts(diff(log10(mydata))),main="PACF Sales")

   ARIMAfit <- auto.arima(log10(mydata), approximation=FALSE,trace=FALSE)

   pred <- predict(ARIMAfit, n.ahead= 31)

   # Write CSV in R
   write.csv(10^(pred$pred), file = "MyData.csv")

   plot(mydata,type="l",xlim=c(1,52),ylim=c(1,6000),xlab = "Day",ylab =   "Sales")

ARIMA models are not very well suited for forecasting daily store sales.

  1. You have multiple seasonalities. The intra-weekly seasonality is usually strongest, so you could in principle work with frequency=7 and hope for the best. However, there often is also yearly seasonality (frequency=365), or biweekly/monthly seasonality (frequency=14 or frequency=365/12 - not sure whether this even works) driven by paychecks. Standard ARIMA implementation can't deal with more than one seasonality. And long seasonal cycles are problematic for ARIMA.

  2. You have store closures with zero sales on Sundays, which you very sensibly set to NA. However, ARIMA can't deal with NAs. You could in principle pretend to have a six-day week, remove all NAs and use frequency=6 - unless you have additional store closure days apart from Sundays (e.g., Christmas). ARIMA will run into problems here.

  3. You will often have additional effects, like Black Friday, Christmas, Chinese New Year and so forth. You could in principle model these using a regression with ARIMA errors, using Boolean or ramp-up dummies.

Your best bet might be to run a regression with day-of-week dummies and harmonics or hump functions to model yearly seasonality, as well as ramp-ups or similar to model any special holiday effects, possibly try ARIMA errors using auto.arima - but fit the seasonality using the dummies, not the ARIMA part.

You may want to look through some of our earlier questions on daily time series.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ @Stephan I am trying to fit a similar model as the OP. I am wondering what do you mean by "ramp-up dummies." Instead of specifying frequency = 7, I set up a dummy variable for each day of the week ,each day of the month (total days - 1 to make it invertible), and a holiday indicator in the xreg matrix and fit a ARMAX model in auto.arima. Would that make the model work and forcast nicely? $\endgroup$ – Matthew Lau Dec 15 '15 at 20:05

Combining regressor type models and ARIMA models and Intervention Detection schemes while incorporating lead and lag effects around events , monthly/weekly effects , specific days-of-the month or specific weeks-of-the-month is also very useful.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ I am new to time series forecasting, do you know if auto.arima with xreg is sufficient to account for all the effects you mentioned? $\endgroup$ – Matthew Lau Dec 15 '15 at 20:12
  • $\begingroup$ In general absolutely not ! BUT if you have clean data one can sometimes get by with simple methods but I wouldn't count on that.. $\endgroup$ – IrishStat Dec 15 '15 at 20:45
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks! I am putting dummy variables for every potential seasonality, but I am not sure if how to incorporate lead and lag effects for events, that would make the xreg matrix even bigger... $\endgroup$ – Matthew Lau Dec 15 '15 at 20:50
  • $\begingroup$ Yes ...and the riddle that AUTOBOX solves ( via very sophisticated heuristics) is how to determine the lead and lag structure around each specific holiday. This is a daunting task ....as one can't simply overmodel it ....never mind the effect of anomalies/level shifts/local time trends etc..on estimated parameters $\endgroup$ – IrishStat Dec 15 '15 at 20:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.