Suppose $X_1$ is a standard normal variable. Define, $$X_2=\begin{cases}-X_1, & \text{if } |X_1|<1,\\X_1, & \text{otherwise}\end{cases}$$

Show that $X_2$ is also a standard normal random variable.

My approach:

Let,$$F(X_2)=P[X_2\leq x_2]\\=P[X_2\leq x_2\mid|X_1|\leq 1].P[|X_1|< 1]+P[X_2\leq x_2\mid|X_1|\geq 1].P[|X_1|\geq 1]\\=P[-X_1\leq x_2].P[|X_1|<1]+P[X_1<x_2].P[|X_1|>1]$$

But I cannot compute the probabilities.May be,my approach is not right.


You have the correct idea so far, but are missing a key trick. Recall that if $X_1$ is a standard normal distribution, then $X_1$ is symmetric around 0. This means that

$$P(X_1 < x_2) = P(X_1 > -x_2) = P(-X_1 < x_2) = P(-X_1 \leq x_2). $$

Using this, the result will follow directly from your last step.


I would divide it into 3 cases:

$X_2 \le 1$

$-1 \lt X_2 \le 1$

$1 < X_2$

The first is trivial, since $X_1$ is standard normal. For the second,

$ \begin{align} F(x_2) &= F(-1) + P(-1 \lt X_2 \le x_2) \\ &= F(-1) + P(-x_2 \le X_1 \lt 1) \\ &= F(-1) + P(-1 \lt X_1 \le x_2) ~by~symmetry \end{align} $

which is standard normal since $X_1$ is.

The third case is similar.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.