I'm trying to calculate repeatability of aggression (ordinal scores ranging from 1 to 6) of individuals. Individuals (ID) are not independent, but are nested within colonies. We know that colonies differ from one another in their aggression levels. Therefore, I would like to include colony as random effects in the model and estimate repeatability in aggression of individuals.

My data consists of 204 individuals from 7 colonies, repeatedly tested for aggression for 4 times. Colonies and individuals (ID) were converted as factors (7 levels and 204 levels respectively) before running the MCMCglmm with family = "ordinal".

The following prior was set:


And the model was run with the syntax:

mod<-MCMCglmm(Aggression~1,random=~colony+ID,data=data,family="ordinal",prior=prior,nitt=500000, thin=1000,burnin=50000,verbose=F).

From this, the posterior mode was extracted as follows:


The output was as follows:

colony: 0.2397765; ID:0.2900612; units: 0.9998443

The repeatability of individuals was calculated as follows:

Repeatability (R) = 0.290/(0.239+0.290+0.999+1), which I guess is equal to between individual variance/total variance. 1 is added to the denominator to account for the probit distribution.

I'm wondering if this is the correct formula for estimating repeatability? Because I get low and unexpected values of repeatability (0.11). Attached below is the trace plot.

enter image description here

Autocorrelation was <0.1. Effective sample sizes were between 360 and 450. Also, the trace plot for colony looks a little wierd?

Any help is much appreciated. Thanks!


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.