# Comparing the difference between two mean differences (x1 - y1) vs. (x1 - y2)?

I have conducted a study with 4 conditions (one control, and three different treatments). Let's label them c1, t1, t2, t3.

Let's assume c1 is significantly different from t1 and t2. I would like to know whether the mean difference between c1 and t1 is bigger than the mean difference between c1 and t2.

Is there a formal statistical test to assess whether the differences are statistically significant?

Alternatively, would it sound logical that the difference between c1 and t2 is bigger than the difference between c1 and t2 if I showed that:

1. c1 < t1 - significant
2. c1 < t2 - significant
3. t1 < t2 - significant
• I think you have a typo just before your 1-2-3, but I get the point. Why not form d1 = t1-c1 and d2 = t2-c1 and do a t test to see if d2 > d1 is signif. But do the ANOVA first to make sure there are some signif differences before you do other tests. And then use some method (such as Bonferroni) to guard against 'false discovery'. Jul 31, 2019 at 8:37
• Fit a linear model. Set c1 as reference. Test the null hypothesis t1=t2 or t1-t2=0. Jul 31, 2019 at 14:10
• $(\mu_x - \mu_{y_1}) - (\mu_x - \mu_{y_2}) = \mu_{y_2} - \mu_{y_1}$ (and similarly for the sample means). You're simply comparing $y_1$ and $y_2$; $x_1$ doesn't enter into it. Indeed if you properly account for the dependence between $\bar{x}-\bar{y_1}$ and $\bar{x}-\bar{y_2}$, you should end up with the same test as just testing for a difference in the two y-means. Aug 1, 2019 at 11:47