If we have P(A given Z) and also p(B given Z), which of the following two methods is correct if we want to calculate P(A and B), assuming A and B are independent? Most likely method 1 is correct, but can you explain why and even even better, provide an intuitive expalnation?

Method 1:

$$P(A \cap B | Z) = P(A | Z) \cdot P(B | Z) $$

$$ P(A \cap B) = \int P(A | Z) \cdot P(B | Z) f(Z)\,dz$$ Method 2 $$P(A)=\int P(A|Z)f(Z)\,dz$$ $$P(B)=\int P(B|Z)f(Z)\,dz$$ $$P(A \cap B) = P(A)*P(B)= \int P(A|Z)f(Z)\,dz * \int P(B|Z)f(Z)\,dz$$


We are not given that $$P(A \cap B|Z)=P(A |Z)P(B|Z)$$

For example $A$ is the event that we get a head from tossing a fair coin. Let $Z$ be the event of getting a head from tossing another coin. Let $B$ be the event that the outcome of the two coin tosses being different. Then $A$ and $B$ are independent events.

However, given $Z$, $A$ and $B$ are not the same.

$$P(A=h, B=s|Z=h)=P(A=h, Z=h|Z=h)=P(A=h)=\frac12$$



\begin{align} P(A \cap B)= P(A)P(B) \end{align}

is true from the definition of independence.

Remark: You might like to use $f(z)$ rather than $f(Z)$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.