1
$\begingroup$

Short Background on Permutation Testing

Suppose I have two sets of samples $P$ and $Q$ drawn iid from distributions $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ over $X$.

I also have access to a test function $T: X^n\times X^n\to \mathbb{R}$ that can take two sets of samples of size $n$ and output a real number. Say we have designed $T$ in a way that we expect it to be lower when $\mathcal{P}\neq \mathcal{Q}$ and higher otherwise, in other words $T$ is just a heuristic such as MMD with a simple kernel.

To turn $T$ into a two-sample test with a significance $\alpha$ I can employ a permutation test to find the $\alpha$ quantile of the distribution of $T$ under the null hypothesis $\mathcal{P} = \mathcal{Q}$. We do this by combining $P$ and $Q$ permuting them in many orders then diving them again into two sets of size $n$ and estimate the quantity "$\tau=\text{quantile}(T_{\text{null}},\alpha)$" $T_{\text{null}}$ is the set of $T$ values obtained by running $T$ over all permutations. We can then use $\tau$ as the threshold on $T$ for which we deem $T(P,Q)$ to be significant.

Question

My question is that when we are given more samples in $P$ compared to $Q$ (i.e., $|P|>>|Q|=n$) but still only a test function $T: X^n\times X^n\to \mathbb{R}$ can we compute the quantile of test function $\text{quantile}(T_{\text{null}},\alpha)$ only on samples from $P$ e.g, computing $T$ on several mutually exclusive random draws on $n$ samples from $P$.

To run the actual test we take one random sample $P_n:=\text{RandomSample}(P, n)$ check if $T(P_n,Q) \leq \text{quantile}(T_{\text{null}},\alpha)$.

This approach seems reasonable to me and shares a high resemblance to the idea of conformal prediction. However, I have not seen it referenced in the area of two-sample testing so I'm seeking some advice before building it in a more involved research method.

Thank you

$\endgroup$

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.