If we define 2 independent variables $Y_1$ and $Y_2$ as follows: \begin{align} Y_1 &= (Y_{11},Y_{12},Y_{13})^T \sim\mathcal N_3(\mu_1,\Sigma_{11}), \\ Y_2 &= (Y_{21},Y_{22})^T \sim\mathcal N_2(\mu_2,\Sigma_{22}) \end{align} where, \begin{align} \mu_1 &= (2, 2, 2)^T &\Sigma_{11} &= \left[\begin{array}{ccc} 3 &1 &0 \\ 1 &2 &0 \\ 0 &0 &3 \end{array}\right] \\ \mu_2 &= (3, 4)^T &\Sigma_{22} &= \left[\begin{array}{cc} 4 &2 \\ 2 &4 \end{array}\right] \end{align}

Then how can I find the joint distribution of $Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22}$ and $Y_{21}-Y_{12}$?

I know its a simple question but I could find if it was asked for $Y_1-Y_2$ or something. How am I supposed to solve it when it is like that?

  • $\begingroup$ Welcome to the site, @teddypicker. I have taken the liberty of formatting your question with the $\LaTeX$ that the site affords. Please ensure it still says what you want it to. Also, could you edit your last paragraph? I cannot quite parse those sentences (& what does "sth" mean?). $\endgroup$ – gung Oct 19 '13 at 14:48
  • $\begingroup$ @gung You are a little faster than I am! $\endgroup$ – Peter Flom Oct 19 '13 at 14:56
  • $\begingroup$ I used to scratch my head about "sth" and eventually realized it is tweeter-speak for "something". The other keyboardism I would like to eradicated is "wanna" for "want to". $\endgroup$ – DWin Oct 19 '13 at 18:40
  • $\begingroup$ What is $Y_1-Y_2$ since $Y_1$ and $Y_2$ are vectors of different dimensions? $\endgroup$ – Dilip Sarwate Oct 20 '13 at 22:58

Assuming that the word independent in the opening statement is used in the way that probabilists use the word and not in the sense of independent versus dependent variable as is common in regression analysis, the joint distribution of the five random variables $Y_{11}, Y_{12}, Y_{13}, Y_{21},Y_{22}$ is the product of the joint distributions of $Y_{11}, Y_{12}, Y_{13}$, and $Y_{21},Y_{22}$, both of which are multivariate normal. This $5$-variate joint distributions is also a multivariate normal distribution in which the mean vector is just the concatenation $(\mu_1, \mu_2)^T$ of the two mean vectors and the covariance matrix is $$\Sigma = \left[\begin{matrix}\Sigma_{11} & 0\\0 & \Sigma_{22}\end{matrix}\right].$$ Thus, the joint distribution of $Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22}$ and $Y_{21}-Y_{12}$ is a bivariate normal distribution which can be found by the standard methods involving setting up a linear transformation mapping $(Y_{11}, Y_{12}, Y_{13}, Y_{21},Y_{22})$ to $Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22},Y_{21}-Y_{12})$ and doing matrix calculations. More simply, the means and variances of $Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22}$ and $Y_{21}-Y_{12}$ as well as their covariance can be computed more directly and used in writing down the mean vector and covariance matrix of this bivariate normal distribution.


Given that $Y_{1}$ and $Y_{2}$ are independent, we have that

$$ \left[\array{Y_{11} \\ Y_{12} \\ Y_{13} \\ Y_{21} \\ Y_{22}}\right] \sim MVN\left(\left[\array{2\\2\\2\\3\\4}\right],\left[\array{3 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0\\1 & 2 & 0 & 0 &0\\0&0&3&0&0\\0&0&0&4&2\\0&0&0&2&4}\right]\right) $$


$$ \begin{array}{rcl}X_1 & = & Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22}\\ X_2 & = & Y_{21}-Y_{12}\end{array} $$

As $Y_{11},Y_{12},Y_{13},Y_{21},Y_{22}$ are jointly normal, the linear combinations $Y_{11}-Y_{13}+Y_{22}$ and $Y_{21}-Y_{12}$ are normally distributed. It also follows that as any linear combination of $X_{1}$ and $X_{2}$ is a linear combination of $Y_{11},Y_{12},Y_{13},Y_{21},Y_{22}$ so must $X_{1}$ and $X_{2}$ be jointly normal.

All that remains is to determine the mean and covariance of $X_{1}$ and $X_{2}$. Given the linearity of expectations, the mean is trivial to calculate:

$$ \begin{array}{rcl} E[X_1] &=& E[Y_{11} - Y_{13} + Y_{22}]\\ &=& E[Y_{11}] - E[Y_{13}] + E[Y_{22}]\\ E[X_2] &=& E[Y_{21} - Y_{12}]\\ &=& E[Y_{21}] - E[Y_{12}] \end{array} $$

The covariance is equally straightforward yet tedious:

$$ \begin{array}{rcl} Cov[X_1,X_1] &=& Cov[Y_{11},Y_{11}] + 2 \times Cov[Y_{11},-Y_{13}+Y_{22}] + Cov[-Y_{13}+Y_{22},-Y_{13}+Y_{22}]\\ &=& Cov[Y_{11},Y_{11}] - 2 \times Cov[Y_{11},Y_{13}] + 2 \times Cov[Y_{11},Y_{22}] + Cov[Y_{13},Y_{13}] - 2 \times Cov[Y_{13},Y_{22}] + Cov[Y_{22},Y_{22}]\\\\ Cov[X_2,X_2] &=& Cov[Y_{21},Y_{21}] - 2 \times Cov[Y_{12},Y_{21}] + Cov[Y_{12},Y_{12}]\\\\ Cov[X_1,X_2] &=& Cov[Y_{11},Y_{21}-Y_{12}] + Cov[-Y_{13}+Y_{22},Y_{21}-Y_{12}]\\ &=& Cov[Y_{11},Y_{21}] - Cov[Y_{11},Y_{12}] - Cov[Y_{13},Y_{21}] + Cov[Y_{13},Y_{12}] + Cov[Y_{22},Y_{21}] - Cov[Y_{22},Y_{12}] \end{array} $$

Fortunately many of these terms are zero.

Given the tedious nature of the calculations you can do a simple Monte Carlo simulation to check your answers. Here is some R code for achieving that:

# Include MASS library for mvrnorm for generating multivariate normally distributed samples

generateSamples <- function(N)
  # Generate N samples from Y1 and Y2 with the given mean vectors and covariance matrices
  Y1 <- mvrnorm(mu=rep(2,3),Sigma=matrix(c(3,1,0,1,2,0,0,0,3),nrow=3,ncol=3),n=N)
  Y2 <- mvrnorm(mu=c(3,4),Sigma=matrix(c(4,2,2,4),nrow=2,ncol=2),n=N)

  # Calculate X1 and X2
  X1 <- Y1[,1] - Y1[,3] + Y2[,2]
  X2 <- Y2[,1] - Y1[,2]


# Generate 100000 samples from X1 and X2
mySample <- generateSamples(100000)

# Empirical mean vector
mu <- colMeans(mySample)

# Empirical covariance matrix
Sigma <- cov(mySample,mySample)
  • $\begingroup$ Then how can i find conditional distribution of Y_11-Y_13+Y_22 given that Y_21-Y_12=3 $\endgroup$ – teddypicker Oct 28 '13 at 7:58
  • $\begingroup$ Given that you have derived the joint distribution of $X_1$ and $X_2$ you can easily determine the distribution of $X_1|X_2$. See en.wikipedia.org/wiki/… $\endgroup$ – M. Berk Oct 28 '13 at 8:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.