I was just wondering if you could point me in the right direction. I have a dataset with 5 tree clones planted at 10 different sites, i.e. same clones are replicated twice at different sites.

  Site Clone  
    1     A    
    2     A  
    3     B  
    4     B  
    5     C  
    6     C  
    7     D  
    8     D  
    9     E  
   10     E

At each site each clone is replicated multiple times. Ideally, I would want to know what is the effect of clone on my dependent variable y and whether a site effect is present. To me it looks like an incomplete block design with clone as a fixed effect and site as a random effect (and block). Using lmer from the lme4 package in R, I would specify the model as follows:

lmer(y~clone + (1|site), data=mydata)    

Is this a correct way of analyzing this dataset? I could also average by clone over sites and eliminate sites. But this way I will lose potential important information as to whether a site effect is present.

Any pointers are appreciated!


1 Answer 1


I think you're exactly right.

Set up data like your example:

d <- expand.grid(Site=factor(1:10),rep=1:5)
d <- transform(d,Clone=factor(LETTERS[(as.numeric(Site)+1) %/% 2]))
## could use development version of lme4 to simulate, but will do
## it by hand
beta <- c(2,1,3,-2,2)  ## clone effects (intercept + differences)
X <- model.matrix(~Clone,d)
u.site <- rnorm(length(levels(d$Site)),sd=1)
    d$y <- rnorm(nrow(d),
       mean=X %*% beta + u.site[d$Site],

Now analyze:

m1 <- lmer(y~Clone+(1|Site),data=d)
## (Intercept)      CloneB      CloneC      CloneD      CloneE 
##       2.624      -0.034       2.504      -2.297       2.396

##  Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
##  Site     (Intercept) 0.0000  
##  Residual             1.6108

I don't think there's actually anything wrong, but I used a pretty big residual variance, and so in this case (probably only on a subset of replicates), lmer estimates a zero among-site variation.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.