I am currently reading the following book:

On page 243-244 there is an example about the log-rank test.

The log-rank test statistic is denoted by the chi square symbol and calculated in the following way: enter image description here

and further on it is given:




I do not want to focus on the idea behind these formulas and what each symbol stands for. I give you the following table, so you do not need to calculate the $d_j$ and the $n_{1j}$ resp. $n_j$.


It is maybe difficult to read, but the Treatment A colmuns are referred to index 1 and the Treatment B columns are reffered to index 2.

In my opinion the given formula to calculate the $e_{1j}$ is wrong.

E.g. let's consider the first 2 j's:

$e_{11}=\frac{n_{11}-d_1}{n_1}=\frac{17-1}{34}=0.47$ and this is $!=0.5$

$e_{12}=\frac{n_{12}-d_2}{n_2}=\frac{16-1}{31}=0.484$ and this is $!=0.5161$

In my opinion, the correct formula is:


I check this for Time (months) =23 (j=7) and 27 (j=8):



And indeed, these are the values given in the table.

What do you say?

EDIT: Of course, I should say that the table is from the book.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.