# Questions tagged [forecasting]

Prediction of the future events. It is a special case of [prediction], in the context of [time-series].

3,579 questions
Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
58 views

### End of a time series have to be "corrected" before decomposition if partial period?

I have a few times series that are Google search terms which a period of length 1 year with 12 months in each year. As we are in February, the latest data shows only one and a half months. All my ...
21 views

### Coding independent variable for regression based on relationship with dependent variable and reducing dimensionality

I have a table where rows are dates and columns are values of a dependent and many independent variables. I want to create regression with a number of nominal and ordinal independent variables to ...
• 1
41 views

### Forecasting Prices with interdependence that form a Timeseires

I have already asked a simmilar question, but i thoguth that this was not phrased well and hence i am trying a new post were i ask a better question. Let me know if this is ok. Judging by some of the ...
• 109
29 views

### Difference between ML models and conventional time series model such as VAR in multivariate time series forecasting

I am learning to use ML model to do the time series forecasting / prediction in multivariate. But I have confusion about them. For example, I have a monthly dataset UCI AirQuality. I would like to ...
• 45
21 views

### Why is my AR forecast better than my ARIMA forecast even though data is I(1)

I am trying to build a time series model for forecasting. The time plot of the data is as shown Evidently, there is a trend component and the series is not stationary. As the interest is in ...
39 views

### Is this an expected behavior of an ARIMA(0,0,4,1,1,1)

I have data of daily sales and want to make a forecast in SPSS modeler, however I'm getting a result that I can't explain. The plot is inserted below. The fit is the red line and the blue is the ...
• 329
1 vote
17 views

### How to deal with the miss# how to deal with the missing values in time series forecasting?

I have dataset in which there are records of stock market hour by hour. There are some missing values like each day should posses 24 values as it is hour by hour but I don't have the value of some ...
• 121
54 views

### Final model for time series forecasting

I am struggling with understanding how the final performance on an independent test set is obtained in a time series forecasting scenario. My understanding is that rolling CV is used (as seen as in ...
130 views

### How does the ARMA forecasting method using the recursion equation and replacing past errors with residuals make sense?

The forecasting method described here doesn't make sense to me. Suppose we have a MA(1) process $Y_t = \epsilon_t + \theta \epsilon_{t-1}$. Let $\hat{Y}_t$ be the forecast of $Y_t$ at time $t-1$. We ...
• 71
1 vote
39 views

### Negative forecast value using ARIMA from fable and NaNs warning using ARIMA

My data set is a weekly data that contains two variables Production and Shipment. Production is the independent variable and Shipment is the dependent variable. First I'm trying to forecast Production ...
82 views

### Time series forecasting: classical methods vs. machine learning / artificial intelligence [closed]

Do you know papers that researched how accurate predictions are using time series or AI? I see more papers using VAR/VECM than XGBoost. Do you guys know why this?
• 21
41 views

### Long-term trend prediction of time series data

I have a time series dataset project (single variable time series) on market share changes of a particular product in a region (values are recorded every day from 2018 to 2022) where I need to predict ...
• 23
9 views

### Why is the conditional MSE equal to the MSE when the innovations of a time series are white noise?

I'm independently studying Lutkepohl's New Introduction to Multiple Time Series Analysis. In Chapter 2, we learn that the optimal (minimum mean squared error) h-step ahead predictor for a stable VAR ...
134 views

### Statsmodels seasonal decompose interpretation

I'm currently working with a time series that has a monthly frequency. It has 3 years of data, 2019-2021. When using the statsmodels.seasonal_decompose I got the following plots: I would like to know ...
13 views

### Judge whether a time series of data is performing as expected or not

Given a dataset, where its variables change along the timeline. How can we tell the trend/performance is good or not? Example: id timeline F1 F2 1 [t_1, t_2, t_3, ...] [a_1,a_2,a_3,...] [a_4,a_5,a_6,...
• 140
1 vote
17 views

### Impact of residuals on forecast

I'm working with ARMA models right now and I was wondering about the following case: If we have late significant lags in the residuals ACF and the rest of the earlier residual lags weren't significant,...
• 25
21 views

### Time Series Forecasting with Different Time Horizon for Comparing Models?

At the moment I am dealing with a time series problem. The data I have is about 6 years and in daily frequency. I want to try out different models on the data and I came up with an experiment: ...
67 views

### How to increase the accuracy of a multivariate LSTM network?

I am using a pollution dataset with values for pm2.5, pm10 and pm1 as features and I am predicting the values for the pm2.5. I built an LSTM network but the predicted values are quite from the real ...
14 views

### What social/economic/political domains are typ. easier-harder to forecast ? Are there benchmark estimates of accuracy for such time series forecasts?

For the report of the results from the Behavioral and Social Science Forecasting Collaborative Tournament I organized during the first COVID year, our team is trying to identify good benchmarks for ...
45 views

### Estimate AR(1) parameters when DGP is AR(2) and the aim is a recursive forecast

I am exploring different options for making recursive forecasts for time series in the ML realm. I have found that it is easier to understand the basic concepts if I first use simpler models from the ...
1 vote
39 views

### Resources/books for project on forecasting models

My professor suggested a comparison of various forecasting models as a topic for my semseter project. Given that my only experience in statistics is the intro course in probabilty and statistics ...
32 views

### Forecasting air passengers, but taking tickets sold into account

The most classic forecasting example seems to be something like: given historic data on the number of air passengers for each month up until say December 1959, predict the number of air passengers for ...
1 vote
56 views

### ARIMA accuracy measures, rolling forecast

Regarding ARIMA model selection and especially accuracy measures several questions came into my mind. To shortly summarize, in my understanding, after necessary transformations/differencing, p and q ...
• 59
68 views

### Many-to-many time-series prediction problem

I would like some advice on how to implement an RNN or LSTM for my problem. I am working in Keras Tensorflow. My data describes the moisture % histogram of a sample of material. There are 42 features ...
• 101
1 vote
47 views

### ARIMA: Understanding how time series analysis is focused on mathematical properties as opposed to best forecasts

Rob Hyndman states: "The paper describing the competition [M] (Makridakis et al, 1982) had a profound effect on forecasting research. It caused researchers to: ... treat forecasting as a ...
• 3,180
17 views

### Predictive model for a set (n=~250) of two related time series

I have a somewhat unique prediction/modelling scenario that I'm working on and need some guidance into appropriate modelling techniques. I have a set of approximately ~250 pairs of time series. These ...
70 views

### SARIMA without seasonal differencing

I am trying to forecast daily data with (S)ARIMA, having observations for the last 180 days. STL decomposition clearly shows seasonality and ACF plot shows spikes at 7, 14, 21, etc. days so that I ...
• 59
24 views

• 1
73 views

### Forecasting via residual bootstrap vs naïve in R

I'm trying to figure out how to apply residual bootstrap forecasting in R using an AR model and compare it to a naive approach that comes with the standard predict function in R. BACKGROUND Here's a ...
• 167
14 views

### Can we do better than looking at an 7-day average of new Coronavirus infections? [duplicate]

If we look at the 7 or 14 day average of new infections, we are always lagging behind. I was wondering: can we do better? In essence, the issue with a normal 7-day average is that it gives equal ...
1 vote
38 views

### Calculations to forecast repayments on loans

I'm working on a dataset which includes the salaries of recent graduates in various job sectors. The data consists of students that have graduated in 2020 throughout the UK. I have calculated tuition ...
10 views

### Creating a module to compare available forecasting techniques

I want to prepare a module for comparison of all forecasting techniques - beginning with classical approaches (arima, ses, also prophet etc.), then moving to sophisticated ML techniques (like LSTM, ES-...
17 views

### Forecasting of ratios that need to addup to 100% [duplicate]

I intend to forecast 'shares' or ratios independently that need to add up to 100% . How can I do this especially when there are >2 ratios to predict. e.g. share of mdot, share of desktop and sahre ...
24 views

### Confidence intervals for next frame video prediction

I'm using a ConvLSTM network for next frame video prediction. The output is a deterministic prediction of an image in the future. My question is: can a ConvLSTM model give me an interval of prediction ...
• 1
647 views

### How well do Covid-19 forecasts work?

I hope this question is in the scope of CrossValidated (I think so because it is in the end about statistical analyses and machine learning, I am not looking for individual opinions but for reviews or ...
• 3,105