# Questions tagged [forecasting]

Prediction of the future events. It is a special case of [prediction], in the context of [time-series].

3,265 questions
Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
0answers
44 views

### Smoothing train/test data

I am currently working on time series forecasting. I know that the first step is to divide the time series into train and test. Then I also understand that I have to normalize the test set using the ...
0answers
18 views

### Forecasting surface visibility with (right-)censored data

I have a bunch of surface visibility data measured at several ground weather stations over a certain period of time. The data for some of the stations are right-censored, e.g. a significant percentage ...
0answers
59 views

### Time series forecast with multiple time series

Supposing that I have 1000 data of characteristics of a machine (Period = 1..1000), with 6 dependent variables (Pressure, Speed, Temperature, Sound, Noise, and Vibration). Most of these variables ...
1answer
32 views

### How to graph ARIMA forecasts vs past values in R

I have performed an ARIMA model and I am happy with my results. Now I am trying to show that my forecast is good. Is it possible to create a graph that shows the forecast vs past values? What I am ...
1answer
40 views

### Forecasting two part ARIMA-GARCH model

I am conducting the ARIMA-GARCH model in two stages. First, I assess the ARIMA model and then apply GARCH model on the residuals from the ARIMA model. My model looks like this: ...
1answer
49 views

### Time series forecast where each measurment is already averaged and has a spread

I would like to forecast a time series consisting of time averaged (everything happening during 15min intervals is averaged and recorded with a timestamp of the start of messurment) quantities (...
1answer
21 views

### Cox PH Tenure Handling

I'm working on creating a survival model to forecast customer retention using the Cox Proportional Hazard model in R. I'm using the tenure of existing customers, in addition to other metrics, such as ...
1answer
55 views

### Forecasting aircraft flights per month

I'm trying to solve a time series forecasting problem, specifically I want to use historical data with an aspect of COVID-19 impact on global and regional aviation, number of new COVID-19 cases per ...
0answers
87 views

### Prediction intervals from Linear regression and Arima for DYNAMIC forecasting

I am comparing prediction intervals from linear regression and ARIMA for a simple AR(1) model: p = lag(p) The models were built on monthly data from 2003-2013 years. Predictions were made for 2014 ...
0answers
7 views

### ARIMA models: maximum reasonable horizon year, validation, model sensibility if extra year is added to sample

I am modelling a yearly univariate time series with 50 observations (1970 – 2019). I am interested in fitting an ARIMA model for forecasting purposes (in R). I have the following questions: What is ...
1answer
386 views

### Time Series Forecasting: ARIMA\VARIMA vs Machine Learning \ Deep Learning

I am working on the development of a time series forecasting, and I have some doubts on the model I should use to achieve better results. PREMISE: Multivariate Time Series: my time series is a ...
1answer
87 views

### Forecasting: best practice for including time-series data with different availabilities (missing data)

I have hourly time-series data with n inputs and a target variable. The target should be predicted at 07:00 a.m. for the next 48 hours. Some inputs are only available until 23:00 of the previous day. ...
0answers
22 views

### macroeconomic regressors as xreg in ARIMA - differencing required?

I'm forecasting a timeseries that has both trend and seasonality component, which is why I am using ARIMA. Without providing external regressors, the best model selected (in training) has the ...
0answers
14 views

### Is there anyway I can limit my forecast to a upper limit using bsts package?

I am using bsts package for forecasting. I need my forecast to be less than the upper limit. Like shown in the below figure. FaceBook Prophet allows this by an option. I would like to do the similar ...
1answer
47 views

### Out of sample MASE

When calculating the MASE, the original paper suggests using the in-sample naive forecast error for scaling of the out of sample forecast error. When i use the the MAE generated by a naive forecast on ...
0answers
21 views

### Calculate prediction interval with stats::predict

I'm forecasting for the first time, so please for some patience. I want to calculate lower bound of 95% interval on my point forecast. I have the following model for estimation and forecasting a ...
0answers
152 views

### Box Cox Transformation in auto.arima

I'm working with ARIMA models and was wondering about the necessity of BoxCox Transformation. When applying BoxCox on my training-set BoxCox.lambda(train) it ...
0answers
28 views

### simple linear regression forecast in matlab

How could I do a linear regression forecasting in Matlab, please? I am not asking for the code itself, but for some guidelines on how can I structure the problem and what to use. I have three ...
0answers
28 views

### What are the recommend approaches for adjusting forecasts made at a detailed level, to match a forecast made at an aggregate (total) level?

Intuitively, I have a greater confidence in a forecast performed on data at an aggregate (e.g. total company) level than the sum of forecasts at made a detailed level (e.g. product). However, when ...
2answers
59 views

### Why is there variation in the trend-cycle component despite using additive decomposition?

So, I've been reading Rob Hyndman's Forecasting book, and I'm now at the part of time series decomposition. Hyndman states that we use additive decomposition if the trend-cycle component or the ...
0answers
47 views

### Exponential Smoothing for many time series

I have a detailed dataset with a lot of time series. If I apply exponential smoothing (using for instance R) it will take me to much time to calculate an $\alpha$ (level parameter) and $\beta$ (trend ...
0answers
26 views

### Seasonal adjustment: Transfer of historical model to forecast values

I have a monthly time series provided by an external source, which contains both historical values and forecasts. I'd like to seasonally adjust the time series using X-13ARIMA-SEATS in R (package &...
0answers
26 views

### What I'm dealing with here VAR, VARX or something different?

I have to implement a time-series tool in my company, and I'm not sure what I'm dealing with, when looking at the old tool. We have one target variable (sales) and a lot of different independent ...
0answers
53 views

### Holt-Winters yields same coefficients no matter what seasonality parameter level set to

really appreciate any help, i've been running HoltWinters on data below, using R. Initially i just used ...
1answer
53 views

### Bayesian Forecast: Credible interval with predicted regressors

I want to do a forecast of let's say orders with a Bayesian linear regression, where orders do not only depend on time but also on another regressor, let's say accounts at time t. orders_{t} = \...
0answers
18 views

### Model generated 2 different results, which is the best SARIMA model?

I got 2 different forecasted results using different orders using SARIMA model. I am unable to choose the best model out of the two below. One have very low AIC but the SR1 co-efficient is close to 1 ...
0answers
35 views

### How to preprocess time series data with a high range for a neural network?

I have a multivariate time series where one feature ranges from 0 to 25 million while another simply goes from 0 to 800 thousand. Here is an example of my data: Giving these values to a neural ...
0answers
9 views

### Runtime Estimation for Multi-threaded processes with varying loads

This is much more of a computer-related question but I believe this requires statistical knowledge (which I'm not well versed and currently reading on the basics) so i hope you can bear with me. I ...
0answers
12 views

### Using forecast errors to cross-sectionally compare quality of two different data sources (using sLDA)

At a high level conceptually, I have two different data sources for panel data and I am trying to compare the quality of each data source by comparing forecast errors from models predicting an outcome ...
0answers
49 views

### Why does the STL function in R identify a seasonal component that increase with each cycle when robust parameter is set to TRUE?

I am working with weekly time series data in R. I want to check my data for seasonality and trend and I am using the stl() function in R. This is my data. ...
0answers
63 views

### get prediction intervals from Winters-Holt forecast method in python

I am trying to output predictions from a Winters-Holt forecasting model that I have made. I have found that libraries like Statsmodels have some tools to do that but impossible to find tutorials or ...
0answers
102 views

### Picking optimal lag values and intervals - multivariate time series

I'm working on my first project using time series: I have the weekly stocked amount of a product and I have to predict if it will go up or down (binary), looking for seasonality, I started trying this:...
0answers
16 views

### Multiple time series prediction problem

I would like to start a discussion. I am dealing with a consumption forecasting project and analyzing a database composed of more than 60k id counters. The goal is to create a system able to model the ...
0answers
30 views

### How to forecast $Y/std(Y)$ using a linear model?

How do I forecast $Y/std(Y)$ using a linear model? I'm currently forecasting only $Y$, and the model is producing results where the larger predictions corresponding to higher variance $Y$. For example,...
1answer
45 views

### Time Series & Stationarity

I know that Seasonality and Trend violate the principle of stationarity, so before modelling the time series with many statistical models like AR, MA and ARMA it's important to remove those components ...
0answers
54 views

### Should you preprocess data in SARIMAX or ARIMAX

Is it wise to scale exog variables in an ARIMAX/SARIMAX? We can assume that we have dummy variables and continuous variables (0-1000)
1answer
44 views

### Quality measure for predictive Highest Density Regions

An alternative to point, interval and density forecasts/predictions would be "predictive highest density regions (pHDRs)", i.e., HDRs for the conditional density of a yet-unknown future ...
0answers
39 views

### Why does my ARIMA model forecast drastic drop at the second timestamp in the prediction period?

I am trying to reproduce SPSS results with python. I'm using statsmodels SARIMAX package in python. My model produces forecasting results which shows sudden drop at '2020-08-01'. After '2020-08-01', ...
0answers
9 views

### Variance Ratio test for 3-D random walks

The variance ratio test proposed by Lo and MacKinlay (1988) is used to detect 1-D random-walk-like-behaviour. 1-D works great for time-series data, but I'd like to adapt this test for imaging data to ...
0answers
30 views

### Using hourly disaggregated data to predict aggregate daily counts through LSTM?

I have disaggregated person level data related to an infectious disease (COVID). I have about 4 months worth of data, which includes information like each person's sex, age, race, etc. What I ...
0answers
29 views

### Daily data - ARIMA forecast giving straight line

I'm trying to create a forecsast with ARIMA(3, 1, 1) and the forecast is giving me a straight line for out of sample predictions. Time Series Decomposition of original dataset: Original data set: <...
1answer
81 views

### Seasonal differencing and auto.arima

I've started studying different forecasting algorithms, using R. As an example, maybe not the best one (due to a lack of seasonality), I am using Facebook stocks. Training set: ...
1answer
76 views

### help with getting my data set up for cox ph (time dependent) to predict within time

I have many observations of data, and survival ranges from month1 to month24. i.e some patients will survive 1month, 2month, 3month, or go all the way to month24. For each observation, I'm trying to ...
0answers
55 views

### Multilevel Time-series Forecasting Model

I wanna do Demand Forecasting of product categories in different countries. The data structure of the data that I have is as follows: Date, Country, Product Category , Sales, and some additional ...
2answers
92 views

### Under predictions in Time series forecast

I have a time series which has increasing trend and is seasonal. I build a TSLM model, with trend() and ...
0answers
39 views

### What is the best practices on forecast by ssa?

I want to use the ML .NET SSA algorithm to forecast someone weight by age with upper and lower bounds. I can use someone data to train a model, but the growth paterns are little diferent per person. ...
0answers
3 views

### Should transformed models be back-transfored before penalization? And should ensemble forecasts from these also be penalized? From the same data?

I have generated a number of regression models in an effort to predict a particular outcome. All the models are based on the same data over the same period. They include, e.g., a vector error ...
1answer
93 views

### Is it possible to predict survival probability of the future (unseen) time points (in R)?

I have a time dependent cox model from 2018 to 2020. Running the cox model, I can look at survival probabilities from time0(month 0) to time24(month24) for each individual observation. Great! Now, I ...
0answers
38 views

### Consistent offset/lag in time-series prediction using Neural Network (all code provided)

I'm using a neural network (keras package) to predict Bitcoin prices 48 hours in advance. The issue is that for some reason, my predictions are "correct" but they are lagging behind the true ...
0answers
32 views

### Forecasting (financial timeseries) - differenced levels vs returns

While I am new to forecasting, I have spent a significant amount of time looking into the stationarity requirement of forecasting models such as linear regression, linear regression with ARIMA errors, ...