Skip to main content
added 95 characters in body
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cumulative and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and a model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulative. Notice that my forecasts are upwards trending for the resultant cumulative while yours are flat.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e. filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cumulative and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and a model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulative.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e. filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cumulative and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and a model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulative. Notice that my forecasts are upwards trending for the resultant cumulative while yours are flat.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e. filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

deleted 49 characters in body
Source Link
Nick Cox
  • 59.5k
  • 8
  • 136
  • 212

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cummulantcumulative and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and an ana model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulantcumulative.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e.filtering filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Hope this helps you and others .

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cummulant and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and an an model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulant.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e.filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Hope this helps you and others .

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cumulative and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and a model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulative.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e. filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

added 130 characters in body
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cummulant and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and an an model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulant.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e.filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Hope this helps you and others .

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cummulant and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and an an model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulant.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e.filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Hope this helps you and others .

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

Your daily data is here enter image description here . This is a cumulative series which will have SIGNIFICANT autocorrelation due to the INDUCED structure as a result of your accumulation. Building an arima model for this is essentially attempting to reverse the user-driven autocorrelation to identify the fixed effects.

I took your cummulant and first differenced it to obtain what you observed i.e. daily realizations.

The correct thing to do is always analyze the observed daily series which is here enter image description here which has a level shift , five pulses and an an model (1,0,0) based upon an acf of enter image description here .

The Actual/Fit and Forecast for the observed series is hereenter image description here with forecasts here enter image description here

Now to forecast the cumulative simply take your last value and sequentially add each forecasted value sequentially to 4.6691 your last cumulant.

The cumulative series is a derived series ( by addition) and will not provide the clarity that you need you need to analyze the observed daily series with whatever software that you have access to that identifies the arima model in the presence of a level shift and pulses SEE https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tsoutliers/tsoutliers.pdf for some guidance on detecting latent deterministic structure.

What you are doing is a typical mistake of transforming the observations i.e.filtering them and then trying to create a model for the artificially summed series.

Hope this helps you and others .

Build an ARIMA model like this one enter image description here

added 75 characters in body
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60
Loading
added 75 characters in body
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60
Loading
added 281 characters in body
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60
Loading
Source Link
IrishStat
  • 30k
  • 5
  • 36
  • 60
Loading