Skip to main content
Extended to a more informative title on what the actual question is
Link

An Unexpected Expectation!: Does linearity of expectation break for three variables?

Became Hot Network Question
Tweeted twitter.com/StackStats/status/1377319811974365208
Source Link

An Unexpected Expectation!

Due to the linearity property of the expectations, we can write $E(X+Y) = E(X)+E(Y)$. But in Chapter 6.1 of the book, "Counterexamples in probability", the writer, Jordan Stoyanov argued that this is not true for three random variables, i.e., for $E(X+Y+Z)$. The paper cited as the reference in that chapter is "An Unexpected Expectation"(1977) by Gordon Simons. But unfortunately, in that paper, the writer didn't provide any formal proof for this phenomenon. And stated that "We have no explanations why the theorem given above should hold for two variables but fail for three." I haven't quite understood why this is the case or found any proof for this. Can anyone please help me understand why the linearity property will not be held for the case of three random variables? And please correct me if I am getting it totally wrong. enter image description here

BOOK LINK