Update:
I also looked at the output of fa_results$loadings in both cases. It displays not the same summary values for varimax as print(fa_results) but the output deviates in the case of oblimin rotation to a greater extent. Which values are the correct ones?
Oblimin: Deviation in comparison to print(fa_results)
Oblimin Rotation:
>fa_results$loadings
[...]
MR1 MR3 MR5 MR2 MR4
SS loadings 2.310 1.350 0.975 1.038 0.563
Proportion Var 0.257 0.150 0.108 0.115 0.063
Cumulative Var 0.257 0.407 0.515 0.630 0.693
Varimax: Deviation in comparison to print(fa_results).
Varimax Rotation:
>fa_results$loadings
[...]
MR1 MR3 MR2 MR5 MR4
SS loadings 2.444 1.450 1.064 0.913 0.806
Proportion Var 0.272 0.161 0.118 0.101 0.090
Cumulative Var 0.272 0.433 0.551 0.652 0.742