0
$\begingroup$

I am having diffculty understanding the concept of an I-map in the context of Bayesian Networks. According to the PGM textbook by Koller & Friedman, an I-map is essentially a set of conditional independent relationships. Let say we have the following DAG:

enter image description here

and we determine the implied conditional independencies to be the following:

C ⊥ P

D ⊥ F | C

D ⊥ L | C

D ⊥ P

F ⊥ L | C

F ⊥ P

How does this relate to an I-map? Is the I-map just this entire set of these conditional independencies or something else?

PS: I did read Explanation of I-map in a Markov/Bayesian network, but I still don't think I am getting it.

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

0
$\begingroup$

Using the Markov condition, the conditional independencies in your DAG are: \begin{align} F &\perp P \mid \emptyset \\ C &\perp P \mid F \\ L &\perp \{F,D\} \mid C \\ D &\perp \{F,P,L\} \mid C \\ P &\perp \{C,F,D\} \mid \emptyset \end{align} Given the joint probability distribution $p(C,F,P,D,L)$, suppose you compute $$ p(F,P), \ p(F), \ p(P) \\ p(C,P\mid F), \ p(C\mid F), \ p(P \mid F) \\ p(L,F,D\mid C), \ p(L\mid C), \ p(F,D \mid C) \\ p(D,F,P,L\mid C), \ p(D\mid C), \ p(F,P,L \mid C) \\ p(P,C,F,D), \ p(P), \ p(C,F,D) $$ for all values of $C,F,P,D,$ and $L$. If you find that \begin{align} p(F,P) &= p(F) \cdot p(P) \\ p(C,P\mid F) &= p(C\mid F) \cdot p(P \mid F) \\ p(L,F,D\mid C) &= p(L\mid C) \cdot p(F,D \mid C) \\ p(D,F,P,L\mid C) &= p(D\mid C) \cdot p(F,P,L \mid C) \\ p(P,C,F,D) &= p(P) \cdot p(C,F,D) \end{align} for all values of $C,F,P,D,$ and $L$, then the DAG is an I-map for the probability distribution $p(C,F,P,D,L)$. In other words, if you can show that all conditional independencies encoded by the DAG are encoded in $p(C,F,P,D,L)$, then the DAG is an I-map for $p(C,F,P,D,L)$.

Note, however, that there may be other conditional independencies encoded in $p(C,F,P,D,L)$ that are not represented in the DAG. If it so happens that all conditional independencies encoded in $p(C,F,P,D,L)$ are also represented in the DAG, then the DAG is a perfect map for $p(C,F,P,D,L)$.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.