Skip to main content
edited tags
Link
ttnphns
  • 58.8k
  • 53
  • 287
  • 512
Notice removed Draw attention by Richi W
Bounty Ended with PolBM's answer chosen by Richi W
added 14 characters in body; edited tags; edited title
Source Link
Richard Hardy
  • 69.5k
  • 13
  • 126
  • 278

Predictive modellingclassification when only greater or less comparisonsranks are supported by the data structureobservable

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which MLmachine learning algorithms give sound models under these circumstances.?

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

I am sorry if my question was not formulated precisely enough ... I hope now the problem is clearer!

Predictive modelling when only greater or less comparisons are supported by the data structure

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which ML algorithms give sound models under these circumstances.

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

I am sorry if my question was not formulated precisely enough ... I hope now the problem is clearer!

Predictive classification when only ranks are observable

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which machine learning algorithms give sound models under these circumstances?

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

I am sorry if my question was not formulated precisely enough ... I hope now the problem is clearer!

edited title
Source Link
Richi W
  • 3.5k
  • 5
  • 37
  • 59

Predictive modelling when only ranking information can be usedgreater or less comparisons are supported by the data structure

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which ML algorithms give sound models under these circumstances.

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

I am sorry if my question was not formulated precisely enough ... I hope now the problem is clearer!

Predictive modelling when only ranking information can be used

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which ML algorithms give sound models under these circumstances.

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

Predictive modelling when only greater or less comparisons are supported by the data structure

I am taking part in a classification challenge (classes are 0 and 1) where the inputs are encrypted (because these are expensive financial data). As the encryption is order-preserving I can only use the fact that e.g. $$ x_1 > x_2 $$ but not $$ d = x_1-x_2 $$

Besides trees, which ML algorithms give sound models under these circumstances.

EDIT: I assume that neural nets, SVM or logistic regression are not appropriate in this setting as they use linear transformations $b \cdot x$ which I can not apply as I don't have the "numerical structure" for this.

EDIT 2: I am given data of the following form: $$ (0.2,0.1,0.5,0); (0.1,0.2,0.3,1); (0.02,0.7,0.33,1) $$ and thousands of rows of them (and in my application more columns). In this example the first 3 entries are inputs and the 4th one is the target. All clumns consist of 1001 unique values in the range [0,1]. So I really think that only comparisons are possible.

I am sorry if my question was not formulated precisely enough ... I hope now the problem is clearer!

added 377 characters in body
Source Link
Richi W
  • 3.5k
  • 5
  • 37
  • 59
Loading
Tweeted twitter.com/StackStats/status/760906126879850498
added 30 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Richi W
  • 3.5k
  • 5
  • 37
  • 59
Loading
Notice added Draw attention by Richi W
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Richi W
Source Link
Richi W
  • 3.5k
  • 5
  • 37
  • 59
Loading