Return to Question

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point? (Assuming the marks are not a function of the position of the point, e.g. distance of the point to some existing structure)

The only literature I found that touched a little bit on Birth Death MH algorithm for marked point process is 'Perfect simulation for marked point process' by M. N. M. Van Lieshout and R Stoica.

In the paper, they said for a birth step, one would have to draw a new point $\xi$ following the distribution $\nu \times \nu_M/\nu(K) $ where $\nu$ is the Lebesgue measure on the compact subset of $K$ for position and $\nu_M$ is a probability measure on marked space $M$.

So it seems like what I did was treating the joint distribution for generating points and marks as independent.

Does this mean the resulting simulated pattern will also be the case that the mark is independent of the location no matter how I formulate my model?

Thanks a lot!

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point? (Assuming the marks are not a function of the position of the point, e.g. distance of the point to some existing structure)

The only literature I found that touched a little bit on Birth Death MH algorithm for marked point process is 'Perfect simulation for marked point process' by M. N. M. Van Lieshout and R Stoica.

In the paper, they said for a birth step, one would have to draw a new point $\xi$ following the distribution $\nu \times \nu_M/\nu(K) $ where $\nu$ is the Lebesgue measure on the compact subset of $K$ for position and $\nu_M$ is a probability measure on marked space $M$.

So it seems like what I did was treating the joint distribution for generating points and marks as the product of two marginals.

Now if I set certain interaction parameters in my model to be a function of the marks, will this method still give me the correct pattern?

Thanks a lot!

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point? (Assuming the marks are not a function of the position of the point, e.g. distance of the point to some existing structure)

There also seems to be little literature regarding it. Can someone provide any materials or maybe explain how one should extend the normal Birth Death simulation to a marked point process?

Thanks a lot!

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point? (Assuming the marks are not a function of the position of the point, e.g. distance of the point to some existing structure)

The only literature I found that touched a little bit on Birth Death MH algorithm for marked point process is 'Perfect simulation for marked point process' by M. N. M. Van Lieshout and R Stoica.

In the paper, they said for a birth step, one would have to draw a new point $\xi$ following the distribution $\nu \times \nu_M/\nu(K) $ where $\nu$ is the Lebesgue measure on the compact subset of $K$ for position and $\nu_M$ is a probability measure on marked space $M$.

So it seems like what I did was treating the joint distribution for generating points and marks as independent.

Does this mean the resulting simulated pattern will also be the case that the mark is independent of the location no matter how I formulate my model?

Thanks a lot!

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. Simulating non-marked point process is fine with me but I am having a little trouble wrapping my head around simulating a marked process. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point?

There also seems to be little literature regarding it. Can someone provide any materials or maybe explain how one should extend the normal Birth Death simulation to a marked point process?

Thanks a lot!

As the question states, I am not sure how I should go about doing that. The main issue is how do I draw a sample from the marked space?

The way I am doing things now is as follow:

If we are in a birth step, I draw a point from the observation window according to some density, then I independently draw a realization from the existing marked space (kind of like bootstrapping) and attach it to the previously selected point and then calculate MH ratio to see whether it gets rejected or not.

But I am not sure whether this is the correct way of doing it. Specifically, can I independently draw a sample from the marked space and attach it to the selected point? (Assuming the marks are not a function of the position of the point, e.g. distance of the point to some existing structure)

There also seems to be little literature regarding it. Can someone provide any materials or maybe explain how one should extend the normal Birth Death simulation to a marked point process?

Thanks a lot!