1
$\begingroup$

I started reading the book of Rand Wilcox "Introduction to Robust Estimation and Hypothesis testing" (4th Edition).

In the first chapter of the book, it is written:

Let $X$ be a standard normal random variable having distribution $\Phi(x) = \Pr(X \le x).$ Then for any constant $K \gt 0, \Phi(x/K)$ is a normal distribution with standard deviation $K.$

Am I missing something or this statement is incorrect? The standard deviation will be $1/K$ and not $K,$ right?

I am asking because the example continues

Let $\epsilon$ be any constant, $0 \le \epsilon \le 1.$ The mixed normal distribution is $$H(x) = (1 − \epsilon)\Phi(x) + \epsilon\Phi(x/K),\tag{1.1}$$ which has mean $0$ and variance $1 − \epsilon + \epsilon K^2.$

I was wondering how he derives a s.d of $K$ when he divides the original standard normal distributed variable by $K$ (instead of multiplying).

$\endgroup$
3
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Everything you quote is incorrect. Even the definition in the second quotation is wrong! But since there seem to be typographical errors in the equations, I wonder whether these quotations correctly reflect what's actually in the book. Indeed, I have been able to see these passages on the Amazon site and in the original they are fully correct: you just haven't quoted them accurately! It is invalid to drop all Greek symbols such as "$\Phi:$" the result is either wrong or nonsensical in every case. $\endgroup$
    – whuber
    Commented Mar 22, 2022 at 14:56
  • $\begingroup$ It's true, I missed the "Φ" - actually an error from the copy/paste as it was not recognizing the character and deleted it by mistake , but the rest is exactly as I quoted. See the Amazon site preview, in pages 2-3 (of the book) : amazon.com/… . If we include the Φ ( Φ(x) = P(X ≤ x) , K > 0, Φ(x/K) , H(x) = (1 − ε)Φ(x) + εΦ(x/K) ), does the rest make sense? The standard deviation is K or 1/K for the Φ(x/K) distribution? $\endgroup$
    – Arg
    Commented Mar 24, 2022 at 8:49
  • $\begingroup$ I have edited your post to reflect what's in your comment. $\endgroup$
    – whuber
    Commented Mar 24, 2022 at 14:17

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

This can be confusing, so let's look at a picture for guidance.

Figure showing how the graph of the CDF changes

The left panel graphs the standard Normal distribution function $\Phi.$ (Because all distribution functions give, by definition, probabilities, we don't have to label the vertical axis: we know it extends from $0$ to $1.$) The vertical red line indicates where some arbitrary argument $x$ is.

The right panel shows how to think of the function $x\to \Phi(x/K)$ where, in this example, $K$ is approximately $3.$ Dividing by $K$ shrinks all points on the horizontal axis by a factor of $K,$ thereby moving $x$ two-thirds of the way towards the origin, $0,$ as shown.

As always with a graph, find the value $\Phi(x/K)$ by looking up from the point $x/K$ to the graph itself. This is the height that the graph of $x \to \Phi(x/K)$ must have at the point $x.$ That is,

to graph $x\to \Phi(x/K),$ we must find the height $\Phi(x/K)$ and pull it back to $x$ as shown by the red arrow.

The resulting graph of $x\to\Phi(x/K)$ is shown in black on the right hand panel.

I hope this makes it apparent that the effect is to expand the graph of $\Phi$ horizontally by a factor $K$ (relative to the origin, $0,$ of the horizontal axis). (When $K$ is negative, the effect is an expansion by a factor of $|K|$ followed by a flip around $0.$)

Of course, such an expansion multiplies the standard deviation by the same amount $|K|.$


Finally, https://stats.stackexchange.com/a/16609/919 shows that the variance of the mixture is the weighted mean of the two variances because the mixture components all have the same means (namely, $0$). Thus, the variance of a mixture of two equal-mean distributions $F$ and $G$ with weights $\epsilon$ and $1-\epsilon$ will be $\epsilon$ times the variance of $F$ plus $1-\epsilon$ times the variance of $G.$

In this application, $G=\Phi$ has unit variance and--as we have just seen--$F = x\to\Phi(x/K)$ has standard deviation $K,$ whence its variance is $K^2.$ Accordingly, the variance of the mixture is $\epsilon(K^2) + (1-\epsilon)(1^2),$ as claimed.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.