4
$\begingroup$

If I remember correctly, in simultaneous equations, cross-causality is also a cause for endogeneity, but in VAR models, the causality moves in one direction, the past impacts the future and not vice-versa.

So why are the variables in a VAR model considered endogenous? Does it have to do with the interdependence of one equation on the lagged values of its own as well as the other equations?

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

2
$\begingroup$

Consider a bivariate zero-mean VAR(1) model \begin{aligned} y_{1,t} &= a_{1,1} y_{1,t-1} a_{1,2} y_{2,t-1} + u_{1,t}, \\ y_{2,t} &= a_{2,1} y_{1,t-1} a_{2,2} y_{2,t-1} + u_{2,t} \end{aligned} or in matrix notation, $\mathbb{y}_t=A \mathbb{y}_{t-1} + \mathbb{u}_t$.

Both $y_{1,t}$ and $y_{2,t}$ are dependent variables, each in its own equation, so they are explained by the model. Thus, they are endogenous. The lags, on the other hand, might seem to be exogenous, as they are not explained by the model... or are they?

The model applies for every $t$. E.g. for $t=6$, \begin{aligned} y_{1,6} &= a_{1,1} y_{1,5} a_{1,2} y_{2,5} + u_{1,6}, \\ y_{2,6} &= a_{2,1} y_{1,5} a_{2,2} y_{2,5} + u_{2,6} \end{aligned} and for $t=5$, \begin{aligned} y_{1,5} &= a_{1,1} y_{1,4} a_{1,2} y_{2,4} + u_{1,5}, \\ y_{2,5} &= a_{2,1} y_{1,4} a_{2,2} y_{2,4} + u_{2,5}. \end{aligned} Thus, if we decrease $t$ by 1, the seemingly exogenous variables $y_{1,5}$ and $y_{2,5}$ turn out to be endogenous, as the model explains them, too. Therefore, all the $y$ variables can be considered endogenous in this model.

(Also, for a specific time period such as $t=6$, $y_{1,5}$ and $y_{2,5}$ are predetermined. This is a useful feature for deriving some desirable properties of least squares or other estimators of the models parameters.)

You can now generalized from the bivariate zero-mean VAR(1) to a $k$-variate VAR($p$) model with nonzero mean, and the same logic goes through.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.